Current:Home > ScamsJudge upholds North Carolina’s anti-rioting law, dismisses civil liberties suit-InfoLens
Judge upholds North Carolina’s anti-rioting law, dismisses civil liberties suit
View Date:2024-12-23 15:50:30
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by a civil rights group challenging North Carolina’s anti-rioting law, whose criminal penalties were raised last year by state legislators.
The American Civil Liberties Union of North Carolina sued over the law, after the Legislature increased punishments in response to protests against racial injustice and police brutality in 2020 that at times became violent.
In a dismissal order sought by attorneys for the state and three district attorneys who also were sued, U.S. District Judge Loretta Biggs ruled Tuesday that the law withstands challenges by the ACLU alleging that the language was unconstitutional through being both overbroad and vague.
Biggs cited in large part previous state appellate court rulings examining previous versions of the anti-rioting law that she declared protects free speech and peaceful protestors whom the ACLU feared could be wrongly arrested.
“This Court concludes that the Anti-Riot Act does not criminalize a substantial amount of protected expressive activity relative to the Act’s plainly legitimate sweep,” wrote Biggs in her order released Wednesday. The decision, barring an appeal, would uphold the law’s enforcement, paving the way for the higher penalties to become enforced permanently.
While demonstrations in North Carolina following George Floyd’s death were largely peaceful, Republican House Speaker Tim Moore and others championing the changes said the laws didn’t deter rioting and looting in downtown Raleigh in June 2020.
Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper, who had successfully vetoed a similar bill in 2021, allowed the 2023 bill with the more severe penalties to become law without his signature. Several Democrats along with the GOP legislators in the General Assembly majority had supported the legislation last year, raising the likelihood that any Cooper veto would have been overridden.
The lawsuit considered by Biggs, who was nominated to the bench by then-President Barack Obama, focused on the law’s definition of a riot, which was unchanged by the new legislation.
But the ACLU argued the definition was so vague and overbroad that its employees or members advocating in protests otherwise protected by the U.S. and state constitutions could be arrested and subject to criminal and civil penalties simply by being near violent activity.
The law says a riot involves an assembly of three or more people that engages in or threatens disorderly and violent conduct to the point it causes injury or damage, or creates a “clear and present danger” of injury or damage.
Lawyers for state Attorney General Josh Stein, a Democrat and lawsuit defendant along with the DAs, wrote in legal briefs that the state ACLU was wrong to argue that its members could be prosecuted for participating peacefully in a protest.
A 1975 state Supreme Court opinion rejected that possibility, Stein’s lawyers said, and a provision added to the 2023 version of the law states that the “mere presence alone” at an event where rioting takes place falls short of the evidence needed for a conviction.
Spokespeople for the ACLU and legislative leaders didn’t immediately respond Wednesday to emails seeking comment.
The ACLU of North Carolina had sued in April 2023, but it refiled its lawsuit in July after state legislators passed another law making additional minor changes.
The 2023 criminal changes raise criminal punishments or creates new crimes related to willingly participating in or inciting a riot.
Fines and prison time will increase, typically by a couple years or more, for protesters who brandish a weapon, injure somebody or cause significant property damage. The law also creates new crimes for protesters who cause a death or incite a riot that contributes to a death.
Business owners also will be able to seek compensation from protesters who damage property, equal to three times the monetary damage. And those accused of rioting or looting will also have to wait 24 hours before their bond is set.
veryGood! (9255)
Related
- How Ben Affleck Really Feels About His and Jennifer Lopez’s Movie Gigli Today
- The Grammys’ voting body is more diverse, with 66% new members. What does it mean for the awards?
- Big game hunters face federal wildlife charges for expeditions that killed mountain lions
- Target's 2024 top toy list with LEGO, Barbie exclusives; many toys under $20
- Trump's election has women swearing off sex with men. It's called the 4B movement.
- Republican Liz Cheney to join Kamala Harris at Wisconsin campaign stop
- Friends lost, relatives at odds: How Oct. 7 reshaped lives in the U.S.
- Casey, McCormick to meet for first debate in Pennsylvania’s battleground Senate race
- US overdose deaths are down, giving experts hope for an enduring decline
- Our Favorite Everyday Rings Under $50
Ranking
- Digital Finance Research Institute Introduce
- Record October heat expected to last across the Southwest: 'It's not really moving'
- Tina Knowles Details Protecting Beyoncé and Solange Knowles During Rise to Fame
- Animal welfare advocates will plead with Texas lawmakers to help cities control stray pet population
- Mariah Carey's Amazon Holiday Merch Is All I Want for Christmas—and It's Selling Out Fast!
- Jason and Travis Kelce’s Mom Donna Kelce Reveals How Fame Has Impacted Family Time
- Mayorkas warns FEMA doesn’t have enough funding to last through hurricane season
- TikTok star 'Mr. Prada' arrested after Baton Rouge therapist found dead in tarp along road
Recommendation
-
Georgia remains part of College Football Playoff bracket projection despite loss
-
Tina Knowles Details Protecting Beyoncé and Solange Knowles During Rise to Fame
-
NHL point projections, standings predictions: How we see 2024-25 season unfolding
-
NFL MVP race: Unlikely quarterbacks on the rise after Week 4
-
2 more escaped monkeys recaptured and enjoying peanut butter and jelly sandwiches in South Carolina
-
Will gas prices, supplies be affected by the port strike? What experts say
-
Big game hunters face federal wildlife charges for expeditions that killed mountain lions
-
Why Olivia Munn's New Photo of Her and John Mulaney's Baby Girl Marks a Milestone in Her Health Journey