Current:Home > StocksSome convictions overturned in terrorism case against Muslim scholar from Virginia-InfoLens
Some convictions overturned in terrorism case against Muslim scholar from Virginia
View Date:2024-12-23 14:20:22
ALEXANDRIA, Va. (AP) — A judge has overturned a conviction carrying a life sentence for an Islamic scholar from Virginia who was found guilty of soliciting treason after the Sept. 11 attacks for encouraging followers to fight against the U.S. in Afghanistan.
The ruling issued Thursday from U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema overturns three of the 10 counts of conviction against Ali Al-Timimi. But she upheld other counts that could leave him with decades of prison time beyond the 15 years he already served.
Al-Timimi, 60, was indicted in 2004, and convicted and sentenced in 2005. Prosecutors said the U.S.-born scholar, who grew up in the nation’s capital and had earned his doctorate in computational biology shortly before his arrest, enjoyed rockstar status among his small group of followers.
At a private gathering a few days after the Sept. 11 attacks, Al-Timimi told his followers — some of whom trained for jihad by playing paintball in the Virginia woods — that an apocalyptic battle between Muslims and the West loomed, and that Muslims were obliged to defend the Taliban if they had the ability to do so, according to trial testimony.
Several members did travel as far as Pakistan and received military training from a militant group called Lashkar-e-Taiba, but none ever actually joined the Taliban.
After Thursday’s ruling from Brinkema, what happens next for Al-Timimi is unclear. He was released from prison in 2020 and placed on home confinement, partly because of the coronavirus pandemic and partly because his appeals have been bogged down in delays for nearly 20 years.
The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond still has not heard Al-Timimi’s initial appeal of his conviction, but it’s expected the appeal can now proceed. Among other issues, Al-Timimi’s lawyers have contended that his conviction violates the First Amendment by punishing him for his speech.
Al-Timimi would presumably remain on home confinement while the appeal is heard unless prosecutors or the judge sought to have him returned to prison.
The counts that were overturned relate to whether they were based on an unconstitutionally vague “crime of violence.” The issue stems from Supreme Court cases over the last nine years that have affected many criminal cases across the country.
Prosecutors had contended the convictions should stay in place, but Brinkema said soliciting treason is not inherently a crime of violence and could be accomplished “through aiding and comforting the enemies, which does not necessarily require the use, attempted use or threatened use of physical force.”
She rejected allegations that prosecutors failed to disclose information that the government sought to use another northern Virginia cleric, Anwar al-Awlaki, against Al-Timimi as an informant, and that al-Awlaki tried unsuccessfully to lure Al-Timimi into illegal conduct as part of a government sting.
Al-Awlaki later left the U.S. and became a leader in al-Qaeda before he was killed in a U.S. drone strike.
Prosecutors have long argued that they disclosed everything they were supposed to disclose about the meeting between the two clerics. Brinkema, in her ruling Thursday, confirmed that she reviewed the documents in question years ago and had also concluded that the defense was not entitled to any of the information because it did nothing to suggest al-Timimi’s innocence.
Neither the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Virginia nor Al-Timimi’s lawyers responded to emails seeking comment Friday.
veryGood! (86)
Related
- Deion Sanders doubles down on vow to 99-year-old Colorado superfan
- Escapee captured after 9 days when dog bark alerted couple pleads guilty in Pennsylvania
- Burmese python weighing 198 pounds is captured in Florida by snake wranglers: Watch
- Abortion providers seek to broaden access to the procedure in Indiana
- 'Survivor' 47, Episode 9: Jeff Probst gave players another shocking twist. Who went home?
- Conservative Muslims protest Coldplay’s planned concert in Indonesia over the band’s LGBTQ+ support
- Stock market today: Asian shares fall after bond market stress hits Wall Street
- What is Veterans Day? Is it a federal holiday? Here's what you need to know.
- Jennifer Garner Details Navigating Grief 7 Months After Death of Her Dad William Garner
- Nonbinary teacher at Florida school fired for using 'Mx.' as courtesy title
Ranking
- NFL coaches diversity report 2024: Gains at head coach, setbacks at offensive coordinator
- LeBron James’ rise to global basketball star to be displayed in museum in hometown of Akron, Ohio
- California man who’s spent 25 years in prison for murder he didn’t commit has conviction overturned
- Federal judge puts Idaho’s ‘abortion trafficking’ law on hold during lawsuit
- Roster limits in college small sports put athletes on chopping block while coaches look for answers
- 2024 Grammy award nominations led by SZA, Billie Eilish and Phoebe Bridgers
- These are the best days of the year to shop for holiday deals on electronics
- Two days after an indictment, North Carolina’s state auditor says she’ll resign
Recommendation
-
The Surreal Life’s Kim Zolciak Fuels Dating Rumors With Costar Chet Hanks After Kroy Biermann Split
-
Los Angeles to pay $8M to man who spent 12 years in prison for armed robberies he didn’t commit
-
Tuohy family paid Michael Oher $138,000 from proceeds of 'The Blind Side' movie, filing shows
-
British judge says Prince Harry’s lawsuit against Daily Mail publisher can go to trial
-
Gerry Faust, former Notre Dame football coach, dies at 89
-
Picasso's Femme à la montre sells for more than $139 million at auction, making it his second most expensive piece
-
Oakland A’s fans are sending MLB owners ‘Stay In Oakland’ boxes as Las Vegas vote nears
-
Protesters stage sit-in at New York Times headquarters to call for cease-fire in Gaza