Current:Home > ScamsChinese refugee challenges Australian law that imposes a curfew and tracking bracelet-InfoLens
Chinese refugee challenges Australian law that imposes a curfew and tracking bracelet
View Date:2024-12-23 11:46:12
CANBERRA, Australia (AP) — Lawyers for a Chinese refugee claim the tough new measures rushed through Australia’s Parliament to mandate curfews and electronic tracking bracelets on some foreigners with criminal records are unconstitutional, challenging them in the High Court.
The man, identified in court documents seen by The Associated Press on Thursday as S151, is one of at least 93 migrants who have been freed in the two weeks since the High Court ruled their indefinite detention in prison-like facilities for foreigners without visas was unconstitutional.
S151 was placed in indefinite detention in 2022 after serving a five-year prison sentence for a crime that was not specified in court documents. Australia accepted in June that S151 fits the definition of a refugee, but refused him a visa. That meant at the time that he could not be deported to China and could not be released in Australia, leaving indefinite detention in a migration facility. But after Parliament passed a raft of emergency laws on Nov. 16, the man was ordered to observe a 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. curfew and wear an electronic ankle bracelet to track his movements at all times, his lawyers wrote in their challenge.
His lawyers filed an application Wednesday in Australia’s highest court asking for the new laws to be declared invalid. The court challenge is the first of what could be several, creating a new complication for a government dealing with community fears over convicts being freed because they can’t be deported.
For almost two decades until the Nov. 8 decision, governments were allowed to keep migrants detained indefinitely if they could not be returned to their homelands. These include refugees and stateless people whom no third country would resettle, usually because of criminal records.
S151, who arrived in Australia on a student visa in 2001, was released from indefinite detention on Nov. 11.
“The imposition of a curfew and mandatory electronic tracking significantly restricts the plaintiff’s liberty, privacy and autonomy,” the lawyers wrote. They argue that the conditions are punitive and breach a constitutional requirement that any punitive measure must be the result of a judicial process, not political.
The government declined to comment Thursday on the legal challenge while it was being considered by the court.
University of New South Wales constitutional lawyer George Williams said there was a potential for more migrants to challenge the new laws that were introduced to Parliament, amended and passed within a few hours.
“It may be reasonable to impose ankle bracelets and the like on some people but not others,” Williams said. “It wouldn’t surprise me if other people come forward, particularly when you’ve got rushed legislation … because there hasn’t been much of an opportunity to get it right.”
Adding to the legal uncertainty, it could be months before the High Court publishes its reasons for outlawing indefinite detention. Decisions are usually announced around three months after a hearing ends, but in the detention case the decision was immediate, apparently catching the government off guard.
The High Court could potentially set an urgent hearing date in the final weeks of the year.
veryGood! (93277)
Related
- Spirit Airlines cancels release of Q3 financial results as debt restructuring talks heat up
- Talor Gooch says Masters, other majors need 'asterisk' for snubbing LIV Golf players
- Kansas City Chiefs superfan 'ChiefsAholic' pleads guilty to bank robberies
- Washington state lawmakers consider police pursuit and parents’ rights initiatives
- Officer injured at Ferguson protest shows improvement, transferred to rehab
- How Sharon and Ozzy Osbourne Feel About Kelly Osbourne Changing Son Sidney's Last Name
- Wildfires in Texas continue to sweep across the panhandle: See map of devastation
- Humorously morose comedian Richard Lewis, who recently starred on ‘Curb Your Enthusiasm,’ dies at 76
- Michael Grimm, former House member convicted of tax fraud, is paralyzed in fall from horse
- 'Who TF Did I Marry': How Reesa Teesa's viral story on ex-husband turned into online fame
Ranking
- Roy Haynes, Grammy-winning jazz drummer, dies at 99: Reports
- Minnesota budget surplus grows a little to $3.7B on higher tax revenues from corporate profits
- Why Sopranos Star Drea de Matteo Says OnlyFans Saved Her Life
- You Won’t Believe the Names JoJo Siwa Picked for Her Future Kids
- J.Crew Outlet Quietly Drops Their Black Friday Deals - Save Up to 70% off Everything, Styles Start at $12
- Social media influencer says Dolphins’ Tyreek Hill broke her leg during football drill at his home
- Kansas City Chiefs superfan ‘ChiefsAholic’ pleads guilty to charges tied to bank robberies
- Very 1st print version of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone sold at auction for more than $13,000
Recommendation
-
US wholesale inflation picks up slightly in sign that some price pressures remain elevated
-
See Bill Skarsgård’s Bone-Chilling Transformation for Role in The Crow
-
Coinbase scrambles to restore digital wallets after some customers saw $0 in their accounts
-
Google CEO Pichai says Gemini's AI image results offended our users
-
Larry Hobbs, who guided AP’s coverage of Florida news for decades, has died at 83
-
Kate Middleton's Rep Speaks Out Amid Her Recovery From Abdominal Surgery
-
Google CEO Pichai says Gemini's AI image results offended our users
-
Paulina Porizkova, model, writer and advocate for embracing aging, is a Woman of the Year honoree