Current:Home > MarketsHome insurers argue for a 42% average premium hike in North Carolina-InfoLens
Home insurers argue for a 42% average premium hike in North Carolina
View Date:2024-12-23 10:40:45
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — With many western North Carolina residents still lacking power and running water from Hurricane Helene, a hearing began Monday on the insurance industry’s request to raise homeowner premiums statewide by more than 42% on average.
A top lieutenant for Insurance Commissioner Mike Causey opened what’s expected to be multiple weeks of witnesses, evidence and arguments by attorneys for the state Insurance Department and the North Carolina Rate Bureau, which represents insurance companies seeking the increase.
In over 2,000 pages of data filed last January, the Rate Bureau sought proposed increases varying widely from just over 4% in parts of the mountains to 99% in some beach areas. Proposed increases in and around big cities like Raleigh, Charlotte and Greensboro are roughly 40%.
Across 11 western counties that were hit hard by Helene, including Asheville’s Buncombe County, the requested increase is 20.5%. The percentages are based on insurance payouts of years past and future claims projections.
After taking public comment, Causey rejected the request in February, prompting the hearing. In previous rounds of premium rate requests, the industry and commissioners have negotiated settlements before a hearing. Before the last such hearing in 2021, they settled on a 7.9% average premium increase after the bureau had sought 24.5%.
This time, Causey told reporters, “we were not able to come anywhere close. So that’s why we’re here today.”
When the hearing ends, the hearing officer, in consultation with Causey, will decide within 45 days whether the proposed rates are excessive, and if so, issue an order that sets new rates. That order could be challenged at the state Court of Appeals.
Rate Bureau attorney Mickey Spivey told hearing officer Amy Funderburk that the highest inflation in 40 years — particularly on building materials — combined with calamitous storms that are “getting worse and worse” show that current premium rates are “severely inadequate.”
Spivey cited Helene, which inflicted unprecedented destruction in the state’s western mountain communities, as well as Hurricane Florence in 2018, which caused billions of dollars of in damage in eastern North Carolina, much of it paid for by insurance companies.
Not mentioned Monday: Hurricane Milton, which grew explosively to a Category 5 hurricane while closing in on Florida on a path expected to mostly miss North Carolina.
“Whether you want to call it climate change or not, there is no denying that we are having bigger, stronger and more costly catastrophic storms than we’ve seen in any of our lifetimes,” Spivey said.
The Insurance Department’s attorney, Terence Friedman, argued that the industry continues to use actuarial methods that ignore what state law requires in calculating rates increases.
Friedman said the bureau’s requested rates are inflated and that the department’s actuaries will demonstrate there are ”alternative recommended rates that will allow the bureau’s members to earn what they’re constitutionally entitled to.”
But Spivey said the Insurance Department’s witnesses would seek to actually lower premium rates, or limit increases of less than 3%.
Without a fair profit and the ability to cover claims, Spivey said, the industry will have to invoke a legal exception more frequently, insuring high-risk homeowners only if they agree to pay premiums that are up to 250% of the Bureau’s rate. Otherwise, he said, more insurers will stop issuing policies altogether.
The “consent to rate” exception in North Carolina’s law has helped prevent a mass exodus of home insurers, as some states have experienced, said David Martlett, an insurance professor at Appalachian State University.
While each state has different models to regulate rates, those affected by more hurricanes and storms are essentially faced with two options, Marlett said: Allow rates to keep rising to cover claims, or “somehow we build structures that are able to withstand climate change.”
Friedman criticized the bureau for citing Helene in its opening statement, saying it shouldn’t be used as grounds to raise rates on the storm’s survivors. He also noted that most of Helene’s damage was caused by flooding, which is covered separately from the homeowners’ policies now being considered.
The proceedings are likely to continue after early voting begins on Oct. 17. Causey, a two-term Republican commissioner, is being challenged by Democrat Natasha Marcus, a state senator.
She held a news conference outside the Insurance Department headquarters criticizing Causey for declining to preside over the hearing, calling it a “ridiculous dereliction of one of his major duties in this job.” She also lamented that any decision will be made after Election Day.
Causey said he’s not hearing the case in part because he’s not an attorney. State law allows him to pick someone else to preside over the hearing, which is a quasi-judicial proceeding.
veryGood! (87)
Related
- Lunchables get early dismissal: Kraft Heinz pulls the iconic snack from school lunches
- Both sides rest in manslaughter trial of Michigan school shooter’s dad
- American-Israeli IDF soldier Itay Chen confirmed to have died during Hamas' Oct. 7 terror attack
- Seavey now has the most Iditarod wins, but Alaska’s historic race is marred by 3 sled dog deaths
- The 10 Best Cashmere Sweaters and Tops That Feel Luxuriously Soft and Are *Most Importantly* Affordable
- Shakeup continues at Disney district a year after takeover by DeSantis appointees
- Chiefs opening up salary cap space by restructuring Patrick Mahomes' contract, per report
- Chiefs opening up salary cap space by restructuring Patrick Mahomes' contract, per report
- Jennifer Garner and Boyfriend John Miller Are All Smiles In Rare Public Outing
- 8 children, 1 adult die after eating sea turtle meat in Zanzibar, officials say
Ranking
- Bluesky has added 1 million users since the US election as people seek alternatives to X
- Five most underpaid men's college basketball coaches: Paris, Painter make list
- ‘The Fall Guy,’ a love letter to stunt performers, premieres at SXSW
- US and Japanese forces to resume Osprey flights in Japan following fatal crash
- How many dog breeds are there? A guide to groups recognized in the US
- Boeing whistleblower John Barnett found dead in South Carolina
- Republican New Mexico Senate leader won’t seek reelection
- Danielle Hunter, Houston Texans agree to two-year, $49 million contract, per reports
Recommendation
-
Full House Star Dave Coulier Shares Stage 3 Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma Diagnosis
-
University of Missouri student missing 4 days after being kicked out of Nashville bar
-
Pennsylvania governor backs a new plan to make power plants pay for greenhouse gases
-
Musher penalized after killing moose still wins record 6th Iditarod
-
Round 2 in the Trump-vs-Mexico matchup looks ominous for Mexico
-
Judge overseeing Georgia election interference case dismisses some charges against Trump
-
Portion of US adults identifying as LGBTQ has more than doubled in last 12 years
-
Horoscopes Today, March 12, 2024