Current:Home > NewsGeorgia judge declines to freeze law to discipline prosecutors, suggesting she will reject challenge-InfoLens
Georgia judge declines to freeze law to discipline prosecutors, suggesting she will reject challenge
View Date:2024-12-23 15:50:23
ATLANTA (AP) — A judge is declining to freeze a new Georgia law creating a commission to discipline and remove state prosecutors, suggesting that she will ultimately rule against a lawsuit attacking the measure.
Fulton County Superior Court Judge Paige Reese Whitaker on Friday denied a request for an injunction by four district attorneys who have sued to overturn the commission, arguing that it unconstitutionally infringes on their power.
Some Republicans in Georgia want the new commission to discipline or remove Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis for winning indictments of former President Donald Trump and 18 others. Willis is not one of the plaintiffs in the suit, although she opposed the law.
Georgia’s law is one in a series of attempts nationwide by Republicans to impose controls on prosecutors they don’t like. Republicans have inveighed against progressive prosecutors after some have brought fewer drug possession cases and sought shorter prison sentences, arguing Democrats are coddling criminals.
The commission has not begun operating yet, and its rules must be approved by the state Supreme Court. The plaintiffs argued prosecutors are already changing their behavior because they’re worried about getting investigated. But Whitaker said there’s no proof that anyone has been hurt by the law yet. Usually, only people who can prove an injury have standing to bring a lawsuit.
“Plaintiffs have not shown an injunction is a ‘vital necessity’ to preventing an immediate and irreparable injury,” the judge wrote.
More damaging to those who oppose the law is Whitaker’s finding that the suit is unlikely to succeed. She agreed with arguments put forward by state Attorney General Chris Carr’s office that the law doesn’t violate the state constitution.
“The court is persuaded that the Georgia Constitution expressly authorizes the General Assembly to impose duties on district attorneys and to create the grounds and processes to (discipline) or remove district attorneys who fail to meet those legal duties,” Whitaker wrote.
Plaintiffs said they are not giving up, still want a full trial, and will take their case to the state Supreme Court to protect prosecutorial independence.
“While we are disappointed that our motion was denied, this is just the beginning of what we expect will be a long legal battle,” DeKalb County District Attorney Sherry Boston, a Democrat and one of the plaintiffs, said in a statement. “We look forward to presenting our full arguments against this dangerous and undemocratic law.”
The plaintiffs say the law creates a bias in favor of prosecuting people, but Carr, a Republican, argued that if district attorneys don’t prosecute, they are violating their oaths of office.
“All Georgians deserve to be safe, and it’s a district attorney’s duty to enforce the law,” Carr said in a statement. “When elected prosecutors fail to do so, crime goes up and victims are denied justice.”
The law raises key questions about prosecutorial discretion, a bedrock of the American judicial system that allows prosecutors to decide what criminal charges to seek and how heavy of a sentence to pursue. The Georgia law states a prosecutor can’t refuse to prosecute whole categories of crimes, but must instead decide charges case by case. It applies both to district attorneys and elected solicitors general, who prosecute lower-level crimes in some Georgia counties.
The law set a deadline of Sunday for the commission to start taking complaints, but two members said in sworn statements earlier this month that it can’t start operations until the state Supreme Court approves proposed rules. That hasn’t happened yet.
Commissioners also noted that they voted on Sept. 15 not to investigate any acts that take place before the rules are approved. Because the law took effect July 1, both supporters and opponents had said prosecutors could be disciplined or removed for acts beginning then.
veryGood! (354)
Related
- Mother of Man Found Dead in Tanning Bed at Planet Fitness Gym Details His Final Moments
- We’re Confident You’ll Want to See Justin and Hailey Bieber’s PDA Photo
- FDA says 561 deaths tied to recalled Philips sleep apnea machines
- Annette Bening named Harvard’s Hasty Pudding Woman of the Year
- Caitlin Clark's gold Nike golf shoes turn heads at The Annika LPGA pro-am
- Take it from Jimmy Johnson: NFL coaches who rely too much on analytics play risky game
- The Best Waterproof Shoes That Will Keep You Dry & Warm While Elevating Your Style
- Police officer found guilty of using a baton to strike detainee
- Rafael dissolves into a low pressure system in the Gulf of Mexico after hitting Cuba as a hurricane
- Punxsutawney Phil prepares to make his annual Groundhog Day winter weather forecast
Ranking
- Maine elections chief who drew Trump’s ire narrates House tabulations in livestream
- Annette Bening named Harvard’s Hasty Pudding Woman of the Year
- Police in Georgia responding to gun shots at home detain 19 people, probe possible sex trafficking
- 'Inflection point': Gov. Ron DeSantis sends Florida National, State Guard to Texas
- California teen pleads guilty in Florida to making hundreds of ‘swatting’ calls across the US
- US jobs report for January is likely to show that steady hiring growth extended into 2024
- Firm announces $25M settlement over role in Flint, Michigan, lead-tainted water crisis
- Netflix reveals first look at 'Squid Game' Season 2: What we know about new episodes
Recommendation
-
Brands Our Editors Are Thankful For in 2024
-
The battle to change Native American logos weighs on, but some communities are reinstating them
-
Federal officials issue new guidelines in an effort to pump the brakes on catchy highway signs
-
Duke Energy seeks new ways to meet the Carolinas’ surging electric demand
-
Amazon Black Friday 2024 sales event will start Nov. 21: See some of the deals
-
The Best Waterproof Shoes That Will Keep You Dry & Warm While Elevating Your Style
-
Authorities capture man accused of taking gun from scene of fatal Philadelphia police shooting
-
AP Week in Pictures: North America