Current:Home > MyIn Texas case, federal appeals panel says emergency care abortions not required by 1986 law-InfoLens
In Texas case, federal appeals panel says emergency care abortions not required by 1986 law
View Date:2024-12-23 14:52:43
NEW ORLEANS (AP) — The Biden administration cannot use a 1986 emergency care law to require hospitals in Texas hospitals to provide abortions for women whose lives are at risk due to pregnancy, a federal appeals court ruled Tuesday.
It’s one of numerous cases involving abortion restrictions that have played out in state and federal courts after the U.S. Supreme Court ended abortion rights in 2022. The administration issued guidance that year saying hospitals “must” provide abortion services if there’s a risk to the mother’s life, citing the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act of 1986, which requires emergency rooms to provide stabilizing treatment for anyone who arrives at the emergency room.
Texas state courts have also been brought separate cases about when abortion must be allowed there, despite bans on it under most circumstances. The Texas Supreme Court ruled last month against a woman who asked for permission to abort a fetus with a fatal diagnosis. The same court heard arguments in November on behalf of women who were denied abortions despite serious risks to their health if they continued their pregnancies; the justices have not ruled on that case.
Abortion opponents have challenged the emergency care law guidance in multiple jurisdictions. In Texas, the state joined abortion opponents in a lawsuit to stop the guidance from taking effect and won at the district court level. The Biden administration appealed to the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which has jurisdiction in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi. But the appeal was rejected in Tuesday’s ruling by a unanimous three-judge panel.
The ruling said the guidance cannot be used to require emergency care abortions in Texas or by members of two anti-abortion groups that filed suit — the American Association of Pro-Life Obstetricians & Gynecologists and the Christian Medical & Dental Associations. The California-based 9th Circuit has allowed use of the guidance to continue in an Idaho case, which is pending at the U.S. Supreme Court.
Opponents of the guidance said Texas law already allows abortions to save the life of the mother, but that the federal guidance went too far, calling for abortions when an emergency condition is not present and eliminating obligations to treat the unborn child.
The 5th Circuit panel sided with Texas. The opinion said language in the 1986 emergency care law requires hospitals to stabilize the pregnant woman and her fetus.
“We agree with the district court that EMTALA does not provide an unqualified right for the pregnant mother to abort her child especially when EMTALA imposes equal stabilization obligations,” said the opinion written by Judge Kurt Engelhardt.
In the appellate hearing last November, a U.S. Justice Department attorney arguing for the administration said the guidance provides needed safeguards for women, and that the district court order blocking the use of the guidance was an error with “potentially devastating consequences for pregnant women within the state of Texas.”
The panel that ruled Tuesday included Engelhardt and Cory Wilson, nominated to the court by former President Donald Trump, and Leslie Southwick, nominated by former President George W. Bush.
veryGood! (88135)
Related
- Mike Williams Instagram post: Steelers' WR shades Aaron Rodgers 'red line' comments
- Watch: Livestream shows scene of Baltimore's Francis Scott Key bridge after collapse
- NYC subway rider is pushed onto tracks and killed, latest in a series of attacks underground
- Small business hiring woes show signs of easing as economy stays strong
- Kathy Bates likes 'not having breasts' after her cancer battle: 'They were like 10 pounds'
- Men described as Idaho prison gang members appear in court on hospital ambush and escape charges
- Uber offering car seats for kids: Ride-share giant launches new program in 2 US cities
- Russia observes national day of mourning as concert hall attack death toll climbs to 137
- Tampa Bay Rays' Wander Franco arrested again in Dominican Republic, according to reports
- Women's NCAA Tournament teams joining men's counterparts in Sweet 16 of March Madness
Ranking
- Kim Kardashian and Kourtney Kardashian Team Up for SKIMS Collab With Dolce & Gabbana After Feud
- Sean 'Diddy' Combs accuser Lil Rod adds Cuba Gooding Jr. to sexual assault lawsuit
- Russia observes national day of mourning as concert hall attack death toll climbs to 137
- Uber offering car seats for kids: Ride-share giant launches new program in 2 US cities
- Francesca Farago Details Health Complications That Led to Emergency C-Section of Twins
- $1.1 billion Mega Millions drawing nears, followed by $865 million Powerball prize
- TEA Business College The power of team excellence
- Who is Francis Scott Key? What to know about the namesake of collapsed Baltimore bridge
Recommendation
-
Amazon Black Friday 2024 sales event will start Nov. 21: See some of the deals
-
Accidents Involving Toxic Vinyl Chloride Are Commonplace, a New Report Finds
-
TEA Business College Patents
-
Car prices are cooling, but should you buy new or used? Here are pros and cons.
-
Pitchfork Music Festival to find new home after ending 19-year run in Chicago
-
New York appeals court scales back bond due in Trump fraud case and sets new deadline
-
Maryland panel OKs nomination of elections board member
-
How a cigarette butt and a Styrofoam cup led police to arrest 2012 homicide suspect