Current:Home > StocksJudge Tanya Chutkan denies Trump's request for her recusal in Jan. 6 case-InfoLens
Judge Tanya Chutkan denies Trump's request for her recusal in Jan. 6 case
View Date:2024-12-23 15:50:46
Washington — A federal judge rebuffed former President Donald Trump's request that she recuse herself from overseeing the 2020 election interference case brought by special counsel Jack Smith in Washington, D.C., because of statements she made in court that Trump's legal team argued disqualified her.
Judge Tanya Chutkan said in an opinion Wednesday that her comments during sentencing hearings for two defendants who took part in the Capitol riot on Jan. 6, 2021 — which Trump and his lawyers cited in his attempt to remove her from the case — do not warrant recusal.
"The statements certainly do not manifest a deep-seated prejudice that would make fair judgment impossible — the standard for recusal based on statements with intrajudicial origins," Chutkan wrote.
Trump is charged with four felony counts over his alleged efforts to stop the transfer of presidential power after the 2020 election. He has pleaded not guilty.
Trump's attorneys highlighted several statements Chutkan made they argued were critical of the former president, including telling one defendant that the violent attempt to overthrow the government came from "blind loyalty to one person who, by the way, remains free to this day."
"The public meaning of this statement is inescapable — President Trump is free, but should not be," Trump's attorneys argued.
But Chutkan said she has "never taken the position" that Trump should be "prosecuted or imprisoned," as the former president's lawyers had argued.
"And the defense does not cite any instance of the court ever uttering those words or anything similar," she wrote.
Her comments referencing Trump in the sentencing hearings were an acknowledgment of the arguments made by the two defendants in why they thought they should receive lower sentences, Chutkan said.
"A reasonable person — aware of the statutory requirement that the court address the defendant's arguments and state its reasons for its sentence — would understand that in making the statements contested here, the court was not issuing vague declarations about third parties' potential guilt in a hypothetical future case; instead, it was fulfilling its duty to expressly evaluate the defendants' arguments that their sentences should be reduced because other individuals whom they believed were associated with the events of January 6 had not been prosecuted," she wrote.
Chutkan noted she "ultimately rejected those arguments" and declined "to assign culpability to anyone else."
The special counsel had argued there was "no valid basis" for Chutkan to recuse herself and that her comments cited by Trump's legal team had been taken out of context.
Trump's attorneys could petition an appeals court to require her to recuse, but such efforts are often not successful. They have not indicated if they will pursue that option.
Trump's attorneys did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Graham Kates contributed reporting.
- In:
- Donald Trump
Caitlin Yilek is a politics reporter for CBS News Digital. Reach her at [email protected]. Follow her on Twitter: https://twitter.com/hausofcait
TwitterveryGood! (55)
Related
- Judge weighs the merits of a lawsuit alleging ‘Real Housewives’ creators abused a cast member
- Draft RNC resolution would block payment of candidate's legal bills
- Vigils held nationwide for nonbinary Oklahoma teenager who died following school bathroom fight
- Odysseus moon lander tipped over onto its side during touchdown, company says
- Florida State can't afford to fire Mike Norvell -- and can't afford to keep him
- 2024 SAG Awards: Carey Mulligan Reveals What She Learned From Bradley Cooper
- List of winners at the 30th Screen Actors Guild Awards
- Kodai Senga receives injection in right shoulder. What does it mean for Mets starter?
- Democrat Ruben Gallego wins Arizona US Senate race against Republican Kari Lake
- AP VoteCast: Takeaways from the early Republican primary elections
Ranking
- Richard Allen found guilty in the murders of two teens in Delphi, Indiana. What now?
- You Won't Believe What Bridgit Mendler, Erik von Detten and More Disney Channel Alums Are Up To Now
- 2024 SAG Awards: Don't Miss Joey King and Taylor Zakhar Perez's Kissing Booth Reunion
- 2024 SAG Awards: Glen Powell Reacts to Saving Romcoms and Tom Cruise
- The charming Russian scene-stealers of 'Anora' are also real-life best friends
- Border Patrol releases hundreds of migrants at a bus stop after San Diego runs out of aid money
- Fatigue and frustration as final do-over mayoral election looms in Connecticut’s largest city
- Spotted: Leighton Meester and Adam Brody Enjoying Rare Date Night at 2024 SAG Awards
Recommendation
-
DWTS' Sasha Farber Claps Back at Diss From Jenn Tran's Ex Devin Strader
-
Search for Elijah Vue, 3, broadens in Wisconsin following his mother's arrest
-
In light of the Alabama court ruling, a look at the science of IVF
-
The rise and fall of President Martin Van Buren
-
‘COP Fatigue’: Experts Warn That Size and Spectacle of Global Climate Summit Is Hindering Progress
-
Margot Robbie Has New Twist on Barbie With Black and Pink SAG Awards Red Carpet Look
-
How to watch and stream 'Where is Wendy Williams?' documentary on Lifetime
-
Draft RNC resolution would block payment of candidate's legal bills