Current:Home > StocksNYPD chief misidentifies judge in social media post condemning bail decision-InfoLens
NYPD chief misidentifies judge in social media post condemning bail decision
View Date:2024-12-23 12:07:53
NEW YORK (AP) — Several New York City police chiefs are facing criticism from the state’s court system after misidentifying a judge in a controversial social media post that accused her of letting a “predator” loose on the city’s streets.
The episode marked an unusually public dispute between court officials and the city’s police leaders, who rarely go after sitting judges by name.
In a post sent from his official X account on Tuesday, NYPD Chief of Patrol John Chell named a state Supreme Court judge, writing that she “did not do her job” when she ordered the release of a man who police say is a repeat offender within the city’s transit system.
“She set free a predator back into the community, who may be on your next train, or walking the streets of our city, looking for his next victim,” he continued.
The missive was shared by three high-ranking NYPD officials, garnering hundreds of thousands of views and several angry comments directed at the judge. Some posters circulated a photo of a New York judge with the same last name.
On Thursday night, a spokesperson for the state court system, Al Baker, said the department had gotten multiple facts about the case wrong.
“The recent social media posts from NYPD officials criticizing a recent bail decision not only indicated that the crime allegedly took place in the wrong county, it also named a judge that did not preside over the case,” Baker said.
The NYPD’s media relations office did not immediately respond to a request for comment Thursday evening.
The NYPD has taken a more aggressive approach on social media in recent months, railing against those who are perceived as soft on crime or unfairly critical of the department.
Prior to the court’s statement, the NYPD’s top spokesperson, Tarik Sheppard, said he “fully supported” the decision to condemn judges, adding that the practice would continue in the future.
“The judge plays a critical role and if any one of us is not doing our job, we should be transparent about that,” he said. “It’s very intentional.”
Steven Zeidman, the director of CUNY Law School’s criminal defense clinic, said the post had crossed a line, putting a judge in harm’s way.
“While the NYPD apparently believes it should have the right to post opinions and reactions to judicial decisions, the danger, on full display by this ineptitude, makes the case why that is a very bad, and dangerous, idea,” he said.
According to a criminal complaint, police arrested the man named in Chell’s post on Feb. 23, accusing him of jumping a subway turnstile without paying and possessing narcotics and a stolen iPhone.
Prosecutors in the Bronx requested he be held on bail of $10,000. But Judge Michele Davila — the actual judge presiding over the case — set him free, agreeing with defense attorneys that the man was not a flight risk. Though he has several prior arrests, he had not missed a court date since 2007, Davila noted.
New York law generally requires judges to make bail decisions based on the likelihood that a criminal defendant will return to court.
The message Chell shared also featured the man’s mugshot, despite a New York law that bans the sharing of those images in most circumstances. An NYPD spokesperson said the department was authorized to share mugshots for public safety purposes.
Earlier on Thursday, before the post was found to have misidentified the judge, City Hall spokesperson Charles Lutvak defended the police chief’s comments about the judge in a statement to Gothamist.
“When misinformation festers on social media,” he said, “the NYPD is countering it with facts.”
veryGood! (943)
Related
- College Football Playoff ranking release: Army, Georgia lead winners and losers
- NCAA, Power Five conferences file documents seeking approval of $2.8 billion revenue-sharing settlement
- Two former FBI officials settle lawsuits with Justice Department over leaked text messages
- MLB's best make deadline deal: Austin Hays to Phillies, Orioles get bullpen help
- Worker trapped under rubble after construction accident in Kentucky
- Canadian Olympic Committee Removes CWNT Head Coach After Drone Spying Scandal
- Dodgers Player Freddie Freeman's 3-Year-Old Son Can't Stand or Walk Amid Viral Infection
- Shaun White and Nina Dobrev’s Romance Takes Gold at The Paris Olympics
- Louisiana mom arrested for making false kidnapping report after 'disagreement' with son
- Fostering a kitten? A Californian university wants to hear from you
Ranking
- Bo the police K-9, who located child taken at knifepoint, wins Hero Dog Awards 2024
- USWNT comes out swinging at Paris Olympics but leaves 'a lot of room for improvement'
- The economy grew robust 2.8% in the second quarter. What it means for interest rates.
- Senators call on Federal Trade Commission to investigate automakers’ sale of driving data to brokers
- Tropical Storm Sara threatens to bring flash floods and mudslides to Central America
- 2024 Paris Olympics: See Beyoncé’s Special Appearance Introducing Simone Biles and Team USA
- Senate kickstarts effort to protect kids online, curb content on violence, bullying and drug use
- Inmate found dead at Mississippi prison
Recommendation
-
Will Trump’s hush money conviction stand? A judge will rule on the president-elect’s immunity claim
-
A 15-year-old sentenced to state facility for youths for role in Kansas City Chiefs Super Bowl rally
-
More Red Lobsters have closed. Here's the status of every US location
-
The next political powder keg? Feds reveal plan for security at DNC in Chicago
-
Insurance magnate pleads guilty as government describes $2B scheme
-
For Falcons QB Kirk Cousins, the key to a crucial comeback might be confidence
-
Think Team USA has a lock on gold? Here's how LeBron & Co. could get beaten
-
Ryan Reynolds’ Trainer Don Saladino Details His Deadpool & Wolverine Workout Routine