Current:Home > NewsUS appeals court says Pennsylvania town’s limits on political lawn signs are unconstitutional-InfoLens
US appeals court says Pennsylvania town’s limits on political lawn signs are unconstitutional
View Date:2024-12-23 11:27:28
HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — A federal appeals court panel has found that a small Pennsylvania town’s ordinance designed to cut down on lawn signs is unconstitutional, saying that its resulting limitations on political lawn signs violates the free speech rights of residents.
The decision Thursday by a three-judge panel of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a lower court ruling against Camp Hill Borough, a town of about 8,000 residents just outside the state capital of Harrisburg.
In the 11-page decision, Judge Stephanos Bibas rejected the borough’s arguments that its 2021 ordinance only regulated the “time, place and manner” of signs. Rather, the ordinance discriminates between types of content, is overly broad and lacks a compelling enough reason to encroach on free speech rights, Bibas wrote.
As proof of the ordinance’s regulation of content, the borough sought to impose stricter limits on noncommercial signs, such as political signs, than commercial or holiday signs, Bibas wrote.
Bibas wrote that Camp Hill’s interests in imposing the limits on signs — traffic safety and aesthetics — are legitimate, but not compelling enough to limit free speech.
“While trying to preserve aesthetics and promote traffic safety, Camp Hill stitched together a crazy quilt of a sign ordinance,” Bibas wrote. “Because it discriminates against some messages, the ordinance is unconstitutional on its face.”
Under the ordinance, residents could not put up more than two so-called “personal expression” signs for more than 60 days before an event, in this case, an election. They could not be lit up, taller than 6 feet or remain more than 30 days after the event.
The Camp Hill Borough Republican Association and two residents sued in 2022.
One resident had been told by the borough code enforcement officer that her three lawn signs — one each for Republican gubernatorial nominee Doug Mastriano, U.S. Senate nominee Dr. Mehmet Oz and U.S. Rep. Scott Perry — were too many. The other resident was told in August that her signs for Oz and Mastriano couldn’t be up more than 60 days before the Nov. 8 general election.
Paul Lewis, chair of the Camp Hill Borough Republican Association, called it a “powerful decision.”
“I’m glad that now two different federal courts have been on the side of the constitution and freedom of speech and freedom of expression,” Lewis said in an interview Friday. “Regardless of your political leanings, this is something that benefits you, regardless of which party you stand for and support.”
In a statement, the borough said it was disappointed with the decision “and is concerned with the potential sprawling impact it may have on the ability of the borough and other municipalities to meaningfully regulate signs in pursuit of traffic safety and aesthetics.”
A borough official said Friday that officials hadn’t decided whether to appeal.
___
Follow Marc Levy at twitter.com/timelywriter.
veryGood! (34164)
Related
- Tennessee fugitive accused of killing a man and lying about a bear chase is caught in South Carolina
- Former Super Bowl MVP, Eagles hero Nick Foles retiring after 11-year NFL career
- Snake hunters will wrangle invasive Burmese pythons in Everglades during Florida’s 10-day challenge
- In late response, Vatican ‘deplores the offense’ of Paris Olympics’ opening ceremony tableau
- Nevada trial set for ‘Dances with Wolves’ actor in newly-revived sex abuse case
- It Ends With Us' Justin Baldoni Praises Smart and Creative Costar Blake Lively
- Google antitrust ruling may pose $20 billion risk for Apple
- After 'hell and back' journey, Tara Davis-Woodhall takes long jump gold at Paris Olympics
- Will Trump’s hush money conviction stand? A judge will rule on the president-elect’s immunity claim
- Kate Spade Outlet’s up to 75% off, Which Means Chic $79 Crossbodies, $35 Wristlets & More
Ranking
- The results are in: Peanut the Squirrel did not have rabies, county official says
- American Sam Watson sets record in the speed climb but it's not enough for Olympic gold
- Eurasian eagle-owl eaten by tiger at Minnesota Zoo after escaping handler: Reports
- Philippe Petit recreates high-wire walk between World Trade Center’s twin towers on 50th anniversary
- Amtrak service disrupted after fire near tracks in New York City
- Rain, wind from Tropical Storm Debby wipes out day 1 of Wyndham Championship
- Utah bans 13 books at schools, including popular “A Court of Thorns and Roses” series, under new law
- In late response, Vatican ‘deplores the offense’ of Paris Olympics’ opening ceremony tableau
Recommendation
-
Disney x Lululemon Limited-Edition Collection: Shop Before It Sells Out
-
Why Gina Gershon Almost Broke Tom Cruise's Nose Filming Cocktail Sex Scene
-
Police shooting of Baltimore teen prompts outrage among residents
-
Explorer’s family could have difficulty winning their lawsuit against Titan sub owner, experts say
-
Maine elections chief who drew Trump’s ire narrates House tabulations in livestream
-
Second person with spinal cord injury gets Neuralink brain chip and it's working, Musk says
-
Why Kansas City Chiefs’ Harrison Butker Is Doubling Down on Controversial Speech Comments
-
In late response, Vatican ‘deplores the offense’ of Paris Olympics’ opening ceremony tableau