Current:Home > MyThe EU wants to put a tax on emissions from imports. It’s irked some other nations at COP28-InfoLens
The EU wants to put a tax on emissions from imports. It’s irked some other nations at COP28
View Date:2024-12-23 14:27:39
DUBAI, United Arab Emirates (AP) — A European Union plan to tax the carbon pollution emitted to make goods imported from countries like India and China has sparked a debate at the United Nations climate conference in Dubai, as poorer countries fear such tariffs will harm livelihoods and economic growth.
Through the tax, the EU hopes to set a price on the carbon emitted to make energy-intensive products like iron, steel, cement, fertilizer and aluminum in other countries. The aim is to both reduce emissions from imports and create a level-playing field for goods made in the European bloc that must meet stricter green standards.
The issue strikes at a core dilemma that policymakers are grappling with — and haggling over — at the COP28 climate conference in Dubai: How to get the world to go greener without upending more-fragile developing economies.
Developing countries are worried that the tax under the EU’s planned Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism would harm their economies and make it too expensive to trade with the bloc.
“CBAM’s sole aim is to prevent carbon leakage” elsewhere in the supply chain, European Commissioner for Climate Action Wopke Hoekstra told reporters at the COP28 conference. He said the tax is crucial for funding and achieving the EU’s climate goal of slashing emissions 55% by 2030.
A recent study by the U.N. Conference on Trade and Development found that a tax of $44 per ton of carbon emitted would slash pollution from the supply chain by half. It also estimated that rich countries would make $2.5 billion from the tax, but poorer countries might lose up to $5.9 billion.
Others in wealthier countries including Britain, Canada and the United States are looking to follow suit.
Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island and Rep. Suzan DelBene of Washington, both Democrats, on Wednesday reintroduced legislation to create the “Clean Competition Act” that would similarly set a fee on imports from high-carbon emitting producers.
Whitehouse, at a panel event Sunday at COP28, praised CBAM as “the brightest star in terms of emissions reduction in our firmament right now.”
“This bill is the effort to do our piece of creating that international carbon pricing regime,” he said, expressing hopes to cut through “a blockade of fossil-fuel dark money and influence in Congress.”
Responding to the worries in the developing world, Whitehouse said such measures would generate revenues for climate justice and improve the pathway toward “climate safety” — the lack of which would “fall far more heavily on the people in the economies and the countries that have fewest resources.”
“I have zero remorse about CBAM from a climate justice point of view,” he said, insisting that his legislation would both grant exemptions to the least-developed countries and focus on the worst polluters in any given industry.
India’s government is one of those strongly opposed to the idea. Former steel secretary Aruna Sharma has urged the government in New Delhi to continue to oppose the tax, but said industries do need to invest in lowering their carbon footprint for both exports and domestic goods.
Mohamed Adow, the founder-director of Power Shift Africa, an independent think tank based in Kenya, called carbon taxes a “trade weapon” that could negatively affect Africa. He estimated the European measure could lead to a loss of at least $25 billion in trade revenue for his continent.
Li Shuo, director of China Climate Hub at the Asia Society Policy Institute, said: “This issue is a significant concern in international climate politics. It’s not going away, and lives are at stake.”
There’s also a technical concern: Vaibhav Chaturvedi, a research fellow at the Council on Energy, Environment and Water in New Delhi, said that under the U.N. climate change rules, countries cannot dictate how others should reduce emissions. Carbon taxes go against that rule, he said.
Trade and climate policy experts say many developing countries fear being shut out of Western markets because they won’t be able to clean up their businesses fast enough. They also worry about being caught in conflicts between China and the West, with China seen as the primary target of the EU’s carbon tax.
But K R Raghunath, founder of clean energy solutions company KIS group, said that even though a carbon tax could be “painful” for some countries in the short-term, it will still have a positive impact because it will reduce planet-warming emissions.
“It will be good for everyone in the long run,” he said. “Ultimately, everybody has to reduce their carbon emissions.”
___
EDITOR’S NOTE: This article is part of a series produced under the India Climate Journalism Program, a collaboration between The Associated Press, the Stanley Center for Peace and Security and the Press Trust of India.
___
Associated Press climate and environmental coverage receives support from several private foundations. See more about AP’s climate initiative here. The AP is solely responsible for all content.
veryGood! (14)
Related
- Gigi Hadid and Bradley Cooper Prove They're Going Strong With Twinning Looks on NYC Date
- Golf analyst Brandel Chamblee says Jon Rahm’s Olympic collapse one of year's biggest 'chokes'
- Robert F. Kennedy Jr. says he left a dead bear in Central Park as a prank
- Horoscopes Today, August 3, 2024
- Police identify 7-year-old child killed in North Carolina weekend shooting
- Video shows hulking rocket cause traffic snarl near SpaceX launch site
- Zac Efron hospitalized after swimming accident in Ibiza, reports say
- Pressure mounts on Victor Wembanyama, France in basketball at Paris Olympics
- J.Crew Outlet Quietly Drops Their Black Friday Deals - Save Up to 70% off Everything, Styles Start at $12
- Christina Hall Takes a Much Needed Girls Trip Amid Josh Hall Divorce
Ranking
- Atlanta man dies in shootout after police chase that also kills police dog
- 3 people are found dead at a southeast Albuquerque home, police say it appears to be a homicide case
- A North Carolina Republican who mocked women for abortions runs ad with his wife’s own story
- 11 MLB hot takes with baseball entering dog days of summer
- New Orleans marks with parade the 64th anniversary of 4 little girls integrating city schools
- Simone Biles ran afoul of salute etiquette. She made sure it didn’t happen on floor
- 2024 Olympics: Italy's Alice D’Amato Wins Gold After Simone Biles, Suni Lee Stumble in Balance Beam Final
- 'House of the Dragon' Season 2 finale: Date, time, cast, where to watch and stream
Recommendation
-
Minnesota county to pay $3.4M to end lawsuit over detainee’s death
-
MLB power rankings: Losers of 20 in a row, White Sox push for worst record ever
-
Man charged with sending son to kill rapper PnB Rock testifies, says ‘I had nothing to do with it’
-
Dueling Harris and Trump rallies in the same Atlanta arena showcase America’s deep divides
-
Kevin Costner says he hasn't watched John Dutton's fate on 'Yellowstone': 'Swear to God'
-
Olympic triathlon mixed relay gets underway with swims in the Seine amid water quality concerns
-
Zac Efron hospitalized after swimming accident in Ibiza, reports say
-
Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Cat Righting Reflex