Current:Home > ScamsAppeals panel won’t revive lawsuit against Tennessee ban on giving out mail voting form-InfoLens
Appeals panel won’t revive lawsuit against Tennessee ban on giving out mail voting form
View Date:2024-12-23 15:47:11
NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — A panel of federal appeals judges has decided not to revive a challenge of a Tennessee law that makes it a felony for anyone other than election officials to distribute absentee ballot applications.
In a 2-1 decision Thursday, the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals agreed with a lower court’s determination that the ban doesn’t restrict First Amendment speech.
The lawsuit was one of several filed during the COVID-19 pandemic against Tennessee’s vote-by-mail restrictions. A district judge declined to block the ban on distributing the absentee voting form ahead of the November 2020 election, then dismissed the lawsuit in December 2021.
The plaintiffs include Tennessee’s NAACP conference, The Equity Alliance, which focuses on Black voter registration, and others. They have claimed the law violates First Amendment rights and “serves no purpose,” particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic and especially for those without reliable computer, printer or internet access. They want to distribute the official applications to people eligible to vote absentee.
In this week’s opinion, 6th Circuit Judge Eric Murphy wrote for the majority that the plaintiffs may have articulated good policy arguments about why Tennessee should reconsider the law now that the absentee form is posted online, but that it’s up to lawmakers to decide whether to do that. Additionally, without the law, Murphy wrote, “mass mailings” of absentee applications could cause “mass confusion” because of eligibility restrictions to vote by mail in Tennessee.
Murphy wrote that “our job is not to decide whether the ban represents good or bad policy. That is the job of the Tennessee legislature. We may intervene to stop the enforcement of this democratically passed law only if it violates some federal standard, here the First Amendment.”
Tennessee Secretary of State Tre Hargett seconded the panel’s reasoning.
“I agree with the majority opinion and trial court’s analysis that the General Assembly has the authority to make public policy decisions, and the role of the court is to intervene only if a democratically passed law violates a federal standard,” Hargett said in an emailed statement Friday.
In her dissent, Judge Helene White wrote that the majority misapplied legal standards to uphold “a Tennessee law that threatens to imprison persons who distribute publicly available absentee-ballot applications.”
“Thus, in Tennessee, a grandson risks years behind bars for encouraging his grandparents over age 60 to vote by mail and handing them publicly available forms,” White wrote. “The same is true for a soldier sharing forms with other Tennesseans stationed overseas, or a neighbor delivering forms to those who cannot vote in person due to illness or disability.”
Beyond Tennessee’s ban on distributing the official absentee application, people other than election workers can create and give out unofficial forms to collect the info needed to vote by mail, but it’s only legal to that if voters first ask for them. If the unofficial forms are sent out unsolicited, it’s punishable by misdemeanor penalties. Those unofficial forms count as absentee applications as long as the correct information is collected.
veryGood! (1)
Related
- Mechanic dies after being 'trapped' under Amazon delivery van at Florida-based center
- US applications for jobless benefits fall as labor market continues to show resilience
- A couple survived a plane crash with burns that would change their lives – but not their love for each other
- Louisiana lawmaker proposes adding nitrogen gas and electrocution to the state’s execution methods
- The Best Gifts for People Who Don’t Want Anything
- 60-year prison sentence for carjacker who killed high school coach in Missouri
- Massachusetts unveils bust of famed abolitionist Frederick Douglass
- Sabrina Carpenter and Saltburn Actor Barry Keoghan Confirm Romance With Date Night Pics
- 2 credit unions in Mississippi and Louisiana are planning to merge
- Panel investigating Maine’s deadliest shooting to hear from state police
Ranking
- GreenBox Systems will spend $144 million to build an automated warehouse in Georgia
- Zendaya, Kim Kardashian and More Best Dressed Stars to Ever Hit the People's Choice Awards Red Carpet
- These Cool Graphic Tees Will Instantly Upgrade Your Spring Wardrobe
- Sabrina Carpenter and Saltburn Actor Barry Keoghan Confirm Romance With Date Night Pics
- Wheel of Fortune Contestant Goes Viral Over His Hilariously Wrong Answer
- Officials tell NC wilderness camp to stop admissions after 12-year-old boy found dead
- A single pregnant stingray hasn't been around a male ray in 8 years. Now many wonder if a shark is the father.
- Proposed TikTok ban for kids fails in Virginia’s Legislature
Recommendation
-
Colorado police shot, kill mountain lion after animal roamed on school's campus
-
MLB win totals 2024: Projecting every team's record for the new season
-
Jason Kelce calls out Travis after Kansas City Chiefs star bumped into coach Andy Reid during Super Bowl
-
Plane carrying Canadian skydivers crash lands in Mexico, killing man on the beach with his wife
-
Kendall Jenner Is Back to Being a Brunette After Ditching Blonde Hair
-
People's Choice Awards host Simu Liu promises to 'punch up': 'It's not about slandering'
-
Zendaya, Kim Kardashian and More Best Dressed Stars to Ever Hit the People's Choice Awards Red Carpet
-
'Black excellence at its best': Celebrating HBCU marching bands from musicianship to twerks