Current:Home > ScamsDoes Jan. 6 constitutionally block Trump from 2024 ballot? Lawyers to make case on day 2 of hearing-InfoLens
Does Jan. 6 constitutionally block Trump from 2024 ballot? Lawyers to make case on day 2 of hearing
View Date:2024-12-23 14:57:02
DENVER (AP) — The videos playing in a Colorado courtroom were both chilling and, by now, familiar — a violent mob, with some wearing tactical gear, smashing through the U.S. Capitol, attacking police officers and chanting “Hang Mike Pence!”
Now, lawyers on day two of the weeklong hearing are arguing whether the infamous events of Jan. 6, 2021 constituted an insurrection under a rarely used clause of the U.S. Constitution that they are trying to use to disqualify former President Donald Trump from the 2024 ballot. The hearing in Colorado is one of two this week — with the second before the Minnesota Supreme Court on Thursday — that could end up before the U.S. Supreme Court, which has never before ruled on the Civil War-era provision in the 14th Amendment.
Tuesday’s witnesses are expected to include an expert in right-wing violence and an expert on Section Three of the 14th Amendment, which has only been used a handful of times since it was adopted in 1868. The testimony will get to the heart of the thorny legal issues the case raises — what constitutes an “insurrection” and how can the extreme political penalty of being barred from office be applied?
The plaintiff’s lawyers contend the provision is straightforward and that Trump is clearly disqualified from the presidency, just as if he were under the Constitution’s minimum age for the office of 35.
Trump’s lawyers argue that there remains a host of questions — did the authors even mean for the provision to apply to the presidency, which is not mentioned in the amendment although “presidential and vice presidential electors” are, along with senators and members of the House of Representatives? Did it target those who simply exercised free speech to support unpopular causes or only those who took up arms?
Scott Gessler, Trump’s lead Colorado attorney and a former Republican secretary of state there, dismissed the lawsuit as “anti-democratic” and noted that one other presidential candidate — socialist labor organizer Eugene Debs — even ran for the office from prison without people trying to use Section Three to disqualify him.
“If they don’t like President Trump, they need to get involved in an election,” Gessler said after the first day. “But what they’re trying to do is short-circuit an election.”
On Monday, the Colorado testimony began with details about the Jan. 6 assault that was intended to stop Congress from certifying President Joe Biden’s election win.
Lawyers representing six Republican and unaffiliated Colorado voters argued that Trump’s violent rhetoric preceding the attack makes him culpable, and barred from the presidency again under that clause prohibiting anyone who swore an oath to the constitution and then “engaged in insurrection” against it from holding office.
“We are here because Trump claims, after all that, that he has the right to be president again,” attorney Eric Olson said. “But our Constitution, the shared charter of our nation, says he cannot do so.”
Trump’s legal team and presidential campaign assailed the lawsuit as little more than an attempt by Democrats to derail his attempt to reclaim his old job. Trump is so far dominating the Republican presidential primary, and the lawsuits to block him were organized by two separate liberal groups.
Seeking to underscore that point, Trump’s campaign said before the hearing that it had filed a motion for District Court Judge Sarah B. Wallace to recuse herself because she had made a $100 donation in October 2022 to the Colorado Turnout Project, a group whose website says it was formed to “prevent violent insurrections” such as the Jan. 6 attack. Wallace declined to do so.
She was appointed to the bench in August of that year by Gov. Jared Polis, a Democrat. Wallace said she didn’t recall the donation until the motion was filed and has no preconceptions about the legal issues in the case.
“I will not allow this legal proceeding to turn into a circus,” she said.
veryGood! (3)
Related
- Groups seek a new hearing on a Mississippi mail-in ballot lawsuit
- Thawing Arctic Permafrost Hides a Toxic Risk: Mercury, in Massive Amounts
- Coal’s Decline Sends Arch into Bankruptcy and Activists Aiming for Its Leases
- 3 common thinking traps and how to avoid them, according to a Yale psychologist
- What Happened to Kevin Costner’s Yellowstone Character? John Dutton’s Fate Revealed
- Duchess Sophie and Daughter Lady Louise Windsor Are Royally Chic at King Charles III's Coronation
- Sea Level Rise Is Accelerating: 4 Inches Per Decade (or More) by 2100
- Why Cities Suing Over Climate Change Want the Fight in State Court, Not Federal
- Japan to resume V-22 flights after inquiry finds pilot error caused accident
- Cuba Gooding Jr. settles lawsuit over New York City rape accusation before trial, court records say
Ranking
- Wreck of Navy destroyer USS Edsall known as 'the dancing mouse' found 80 years after sinking
- Daily 'breath training' can work as well as medicine to reduce high blood pressure
- Biden touts his 'cancer moonshot' on the anniversary of JFK's 'man on the moon' speech
- Scientists debate how lethal COVID is. Some say it's now less risky than flu
- 'I heard it and felt it': Chemical facility explosion leaves 11 hospitalized in Louisville
- Dirtier Than Coal? Under Fire, Institute Clarifies Its Claim About Biomass
- Is California’s Drought Returning? Snowpack Nears 2015’s Historic Lows
- Overlooked Tiny Air Pollutants Can Have Major Climate Impact
Recommendation
-
Why Game of Thrones' Maisie Williams May Be Rejoining the George R.R. Martin Universe
-
Microsoft to pay $20 million over FTC charges surrounding kids' data collection
-
The economics behind 'quiet quitting' — and what we should call it instead
-
Trump the Environmentalist?
-
Indiana man is found guilty of murder in the 2017 killings of 2 teenage girls
-
Texas Fracking Zone Emits 90% More Methane Than EPA Estimated
-
Poverty and uninsured rates drop, thanks to pandemic-era policies
-
Climate and Weather Disasters Cost U.S. a Record $306 Billion in 2017