Current:Home > ScamsGOP impeachment effort against Philadelphia prosecutor lands before Democratic-majority court-InfoLens
GOP impeachment effort against Philadelphia prosecutor lands before Democratic-majority court
View Date:2024-12-23 12:01:34
HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — Pennsylvania’s highest court on Tuesday weighed whether the Legislature can proceed with an impeachment trial against Philadelphia’s elected progressive prosecutor and whether the court or lawmakers should determine what qualifies as misbehavior in office.
What the justices decide after oral arguments in the Supreme Court chambers in Harrisburg will determine the future of efforts to remove District Attorney Larry Krasner, a Democrat, on claims he should have prosecuted some minor crimes, his bail policies and how he has managed his office.
Krasner was impeached by the state House in November 2022, a year after he was overwhelmingly reelected to a second term, sending the matter to the state Senate for trial.
Justice Kevin Brobson, one of the two Republicans on the bench Tuesday, questioned why the court should get involved at this point and suggested the Senate may not get the two-thirds majority necessary to convict and remove Krasner from office.
“Just as I would not want the General Assembly to stick its nose into a court proceeding, I am shy about whether it makes sense, constitutionally, jurisprudentially, for us at this stage to stick our noses” into the impeachment process, he said.
Justice Christine Donohue, among the four Democratic justices at the hearing, said she was not comfortable delving “into the weeds” of what the impeachable offenses were, but indicated it should be up to the Supreme Court to define misbehavior in office, the grounds for removal.
“It would go through the Senate once we define what misbehavior in office means, whatever that is, and then it would never come back again because then there would be a definition of what misbehavior in office is,” she said.
Another Democrat, Justice David Wecht, seemed to chafe at an argument by lawyers for the two Republican House members managing the impeachment trial that lawmakers should determine what constitutes misbehavior.
“It’s not just akin to indicting a ham sandwich,” Wecht said. He went on to say, “They could have totally different ham sandwiches in mind.”
“I mean, it’s whatever the House wakes up to today and what they have for breakfast and then they bring impeachment. And then tomorrow the Senate wakes up and they think of the polar opposite as what any misbehavior means,” Wecht said.
Krasner has dismissed the House Republicans’ claims as targeting his policies, and a lower court issued a split ruling in the matter.
A panel of lower-court judges rejected two of Krasner’s challenges — that the opportunity for a trial died along with the end last year’s session and that as a local official he could not be impeached by the General Assembly. But it agreed with him that the impeachment articles do not meet the state constitution’s definition of misbehavior in office.
Krasner’s appeal seeks reconsideration of the Commonwealth Court’s decision.
The Republican representatives who spearheaded the impeachment and the GOP-controlled Senate leadership also appealed, arguing that impeachment proceedings exist outside of the rules of lawmaking and could continue into a new legislative session. Krasner, as a district attorney, gets state funding and that distinguishes him from purely local officials, they argued.
__
Brooke Schultz is a corps member for the Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues.
veryGood! (34677)
Related
- Will Aaron Rodgers retire? Jets QB tells reporters he plans to play in 2025
- Moving to a college dorm? Here's how you can choose a reliable mover and avoid scams
- Simone Biles is trying to enjoy the moment after a two-year break. The Olympic talk can come later
- 2 killed, 3 hurt when pleasure boat catches fire in bay south of Los Angeles
- New Pentagon report on UFOs includes hundreds of new incidents but no evidence of aliens
- An Indigenous leader has inspired an Amazon city to grant personhood to an endangered river
- Bloomsbury USA President Adrienne Vaughan Killed During Boating Accident in Italy's Amalfi Coast
- Paying too much for auto insurance? 4 reasons to go over your budget now.
- Patrick Mahomes Breaks Silence on Frustrating Robbery Amid Ongoing Investigation
- Southwest employee accused white mom of trafficking her Black daughter, lawsuit says
Ranking
- College football Week 12 expert picks for every Top 25 game include SEC showdowns
- Iran opens registration for candidates in next year’s parliament election, the first since protests
- What caused an Alaskan glacier to cause major flooding near Juneau
- Maralee Nichols Shares Glimpse Inside Farm Trip With Her and Tristan Thompson’s Son Theo
- NYC bans unusual practice of forcing tenants to pay real estate brokers hired by landlords
- CBS News poll finds after latest Trump indictment, many Americans see implications for democracy. For some, it's personal
- The Mega Millions jackpot has soared to $1.55 billion. Here’s how hard it is to win
- An Indigenous leader has inspired an Amazon city to grant personhood to an endangered river
Recommendation
-
Sofia Richie Reveals 5-Month-Old Daughter Eloise Has a Real Phone
-
Simone Biles is trying to enjoy the moment after a two-year break. The Olympic talk can come later
-
That's Billionaire 'Barbie' to you: The biggest movie of summer hits $1B at box office
-
Trump effort to overturn election 'aspirational', U.S. out of World Cup: 5 Things podcast
-
Nicky Hilton Shares Her Christmas Plans With Paris, the Secret To Perfect Skin & More Holiday Gift Picks
-
Coco Gauff defeats Maria Sakkari in DC Open final for her fourth WTA singles title
-
Indictment ignored, Trump barely a mention, as GOP candidates pitch Iowa voters to challenge him
-
Montgomery police say 4 active warrants out after brawl at Riverfront Park in Alabama