Current:Home > NewsFederal appeals court rejects Alex Murdaugh’s appeal that his 40-year theft sentence is too harsh-InfoLens
Federal appeals court rejects Alex Murdaugh’s appeal that his 40-year theft sentence is too harsh
View Date:2024-12-23 11:59:38
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — A federal court has rejected Alex Murdaugh’s request to throw out his 40-year sentence for stealing from clients and his law firm. The disgraced South Carolina lawyer said his punishment is a decade longer than what prosecutors recommended.
U.S. District Judge Richard Gergel said in April that he chose a harsher prison sentence because Murdaugh stole from “the most needy, vulnerable people,” clients who were maimed in wrecks or lost loved ones and had placed all their problems and all their hopes with the now disbarred attorney.
The U.S. Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals decided Tuesday to dismiss the appeal, saying in a two-page ruling that when Murdaugh agreed to plead guilty, he waived his right to appeal except in extraordinary circumstances, and a harsher-than-expected sentence didn’t count.
Murdaugh’s lawyers said they are now considering their options. The 40-year federal sentence has been considered a backstop, in case the 56-year-old Murdaugh wins a separate appeal of the life sentence he’s serving in a South Carolina prison for the killings of his wife and son.
Murdaugh testified in his own defense at trial, adamantly denying that he shot his family. The South Carolina Supreme Court agreed to consider whether his murder convictions should be tossed out because his lawyers said a clerk may have tampered with the jury.
In the federal theft case, Murdaugh’s lawyers said his right against cruel and unusual punishment under the U.S. Constitution was violated because Gergel ignored the 17 1/2 years to just under 22 years in prison recommended by federal agents and the 30 years suggested by prosecutors when he sentenced Murdaugh to 40 years.
In response to his appeal, federal prosecutors noted simply that when Murdaugh agreed to plead guilty, he signed a document saying he wouldn’t appeal unless prosecutors lied or his defense attorneys were inadequate.
Murdaugh admitted that he stole from his clients in wrongful death and injury cases. In handing down the stiff sentence, Gergel mentioned stealing from a state trooper who was injured on the job and a trust fund intended for children whose parents were killed in a wreck.
Those people “placed all their problems and all their hopes” with their lawyer, Gergel said.
Murdaugh’s attorneys compared his case to the 25 years in prison for crypto entrepreneur Sam Bankman-Fried and the 11-year sentence handed down to Theranos CEO Elizabeth Holmes, saying they stole billions while Murdaugh merely stole millions.
But the victims in those cases were investors, whereas Murdaugh stole from vulnerable people who trusted him to protect their legal interests.
Even though this federal appeal was rejected, Murdaugh’s cases will remain in appellate courts for years.
Courts haven’t even begun hearing the meat of Murdaugh’s argument that the judge in his murder trial made mistakes, for example by allowing his money thefts into evidence. That was critical to the prosecution’s argument that the killings were meant to buy sympathy and time to keep the thefts from being discovered.
Investigators said Murdaugh was addicted to opioids and his complex schemes to steal money from clients and his family’s law firm were starting to unravel when he shot his younger son, Paul, with a shotgun and his wife, Maggie, with a rifle at their home in Colleton County in 2021.
veryGood! (25)
Related
- 'America's flagship' SS United States has departure from Philadelphia to Florida delayed
- Off-duty Arkansas officer kills shoplifting suspect who attacked him with a knife, police say
- Hong Kong prosecutors allege democracy publisher Jimmy Lai urged protests, sanctions against China
- Gun restriction bills on tap in Maine Legislature after state’s deadliest mass shooting
- Voters in California city reject measure allowing noncitizens to vote in local races
- As Atlantic City adds more security cameras, 2 men are killed in areas already covered by them
- New tech devices for the holidays? Here's how to secure your privacy
- Washington's Michael Penix Jr. dazzles in Sugar Bowl defeat of Texas: See his top plays
- Officer injured at Ferguson protest shows improvement, transferred to rehab
- Souvenir sellers have flooded the Brooklyn Bridge. Now the city is banning them
Ranking
- DWTS' Sasha Farber Claps Back at Diss From Jenn Tran's Ex Devin Strader
- How to Watch the 2024 Golden Globes Ceremony on TV and Online
- US women are stocking up on abortion pills, especially when there is news about restrictions
- Why Michigan expected Alabama's play-call on last snap of Rose Bowl
- Michigan soldier’s daughter finally took a long look at his 250 WWII letters
- NBA power rankings: Are the Clippers and Suns ready to contend in the West?
- 1,400-pound great white shark makes New Year's appearance off Florida coast after 34,000-mile journey
- Pretty Little Liars’ Lucy Hale Marks Two Years of Sobriety
Recommendation
-
13 escaped monkeys still on the loose in South Carolina after 30 were recaptured
-
Marvel Actress Carrie Bernans Hospitalized After Traumatic Hit-and-Run Incident
-
What's open today? New Year's Day hours for restaurants, stores and fast-food places.
-
New Mexico regulators revoke the licenses of 2 marijuana grow operations and levies $2M in fines
-
Why was Jalen Ramsey traded? Dolphins CB facing former team on 'Monday Night Football'
-
How to Watch the 2024 Golden Globes Ceremony on TV and Online
-
Blake Lively Proudly Shows Off Her Interior Design Skills in Peek Inside Her Home
-
Prosecutors recommend six months in prison for a man at the center of a Jan. 6 conspiracy theory