Current:Home > NewsFederal judge denies temporary restraining order in Tennessee's NIL case against NCAA-InfoLens
Federal judge denies temporary restraining order in Tennessee's NIL case against NCAA
View Date:2024-12-23 10:41:00
A federal judge denied a requested temporary restraining order Tuesday, creating a speed bump for the states of Tennessee and Virginia in their quest to pause NCAA rules regarding name, image and likeness benefits for college athletes.
The ruling leaves the current NIL rules in place for Wednesday, the start of the Division I football regular signing period, when recruits can sign a letter of intent with a university. The same judge will hear arguments for a lengthier preliminary injunction in a Greeneville, Tennessee courtroom Feb. 13.
That hearing could have seismic and long-term effects on college sports if the NCAA's rules banning NIL recruiting inducements and pay-for-play deals are put on hold.
The order was issued in the Eastern Tennessee District of federal court in Greeneville, not far from where the University of Tennessee is locked in a fierce fight with the NCAA over NIL rules.
The Feb. 13 hearing could result in a temporary injunction which, if granted, would remain the rule until at least the end of the lawsuit.
Regardless, a decision on a temporary restraining order does not guarantee a similar result with a temporary injunction, or vice versa.
Previously, recruits could only sign NIL deals before enrolling in a university if their state laws permitted it. But the NCAA could view parts of those arrangements as recruiting inducements, which violates its rules.
That ambiguity remains, as does Tennessee's place as the epicenter of a potential earthquake in college sports.
How Tennessee became ground zero for fight against NCAA
The denied restraining order is part of the antitrust lawsuit filed by Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti, along with the state of Virginia, against the NCAA over its “NIL-recruiting ban.”
The suit is running parallel to the NCAA’s ongoing investigation into allegations that the University of Tennessee broke rules involving NIL of athletes.
The suit and the investigation are not directly linked. But the attorney general’s suit mentions the Tennessee investigation as an example of the “unlawful restriction” of the NCAA's NIL policy, and it immediately drew support from Gov. Bill Lee and other state officials.
An injunction from the court wouldn't end the NCAA investigation into Tennessee athletics, but it would add a snag. The NCAA would then be trying to investigate and seek to punish the school over rules that it can not currently enforce.
In a declaration filed with Skrmetti's original complaint, Tennessee athletic director Danny White encouraged the court to remove the NIL rules before signing day.
“After the February 7 regular signing period, these football players will not have any negotiating power and will be subject to marketing restraints at their selected schools … If schools were permitted to discuss NIL opportunities during the recruiting process, schools would be fiercely competing with other institutions to recruit the best athletes," he wrote.
Over the weekend the two sides exchanged fiery responses, with the NCAA, among other things, thumbing its nose at the state of Tennessee and saying the state failed to show the importance of a Feb. 7 deadline and failed to prove there would be irreparable harm to athletes.
The response pointed to the lone example given by Tennessee, Volunteers football player Jackson Lampley, who was not recruited during the NIL era but filed a declaration of his availability to testify.
The state's reply was to the point.
"The NCAA seemingly wants a testimonial from a current high schooler … That’s convenient, since the NCAA knows no current recruit would risk incurring the NCAA’s wrath by admitting he has (or would like to) violate its rules,” it said.
veryGood! (4)
Related
- Eva Longoria Shares She and Her Family Have Moved Out of the United States
- Dance Mom's Abby Lee Miller Makes Surprising Appearance at 2024 Emmys
- 2024 Emmys: Christine Baranski and Daughter Lily Cowles Enjoy Rare Red Carpet Moment Together
- Florida State's fall to 0-3 has Mike Norvell's team leading college football's Week 3 Misery Index
- The White Stripes drop lawsuit against Donald Trump over 'Seven Nation Army' use
- What We Do in the Shadows Gifts for All…but Not You, Guillermo
- Reese Witherspoon Reveals Epic Present Laura Dern Gave Her Son at 2024 Emmys
- Police: 4 killed after multi-vehicle crash in southeast Dallas
- Wisconsin agency issues first round of permits for Enbridge Line 5 reroute around reservation
- Four Downs and a Bracket: Billy Napier era at Florida nears end with boosters ready to pay buyout
Ranking
- Congress returns to unfinished business and a new Trump era
- Who Is In the Banana Costume at the 2024 Emmy Awards? How a Reality Star Stole the Red Carpet Spotlight
- 'Rarefied air': Ganassi's Alex Palou wins third IndyCar title in four years
- Travis Hunter shines as Colorado takes care of business against Colorado State: Highlights
- Chiefs block last-second field goal to save unbeaten record, beat Broncos
- Arizona man accused of online terror threats has been arrested in Montana
- NFL schedule today: Everything to know about Week 2 games on Sunday
- How Baby Reindeer's Richard Gadd Became the Star of the 2024 Emmys
Recommendation
-
What happens to Donald Trump’s criminal conviction? Here are a few ways it could go
-
Taylor Swift's Mom Andrea Swift Wears Sweet Tribute to Travis Kelce at Chiefs Game
-
Which candidate is better for tech innovation? Venture capitalists divided on Harris or Trump
-
Buying a house? Four unconventional ways to become a homeowner.
-
Watch: Military dad's emotional return after a year away
-
What game is Tom Brady broadcasting in Week 2? Where to listen to Fox NFL analyst
-
2024 Emmys: Jodie Foster Shares Special Message for Wife Alexandra Hedison
-
Prince William Sends Prince Harry Rare Message on 40th Birthday Amid Family Rift