Current:Home > MyJudge criticizes Trump’s expert witness as he again refuses to toss fraud lawsuit-InfoLens
Judge criticizes Trump’s expert witness as he again refuses to toss fraud lawsuit
View Date:2024-12-23 14:19:39
NEW YORK (AP) — Former President Donald Trump has lost his latest bid to end the business fraud lawsuit he faces in New York as he campaigns to reclaim the White House.
Judge Arthur Engoron issued a written ruling Monday denying the Republican’s latest request for a verdict in his favor in a lawsuit brought by New York Attorney General Letitia James.
And in doing so, the judge dismissed the credibility of one of Trump’s expert witnesses at the trial, a professor who testified that he saw no fraud in the former president’s financial statements.
The trial is centered on allegations Trump and other company officials exaggerated his wealth and inflated the value of his assets to secure loans and close business deals.
In the three-page ruling, Engoron wrote that the “most glaring” flaw of Trump’s argument was to assume that the testimony provided by Eli Bartov, an accounting professor at New York University, and other expert witnesses would be accepted by the court as “true and accurate.”
“Bartov is a tenured professor, but the only thing his testimony proves is that for a million or so dollars, some experts will say whatever you want them to say,” Engoron wrote.
Bartov, who was paid nearly $900,000 for his work on the trial, said in an email that the judge had mischaracterized his testimony.
Trump took to his defense, calling Engoron’s comments about Bartov a “great insult to a man of impeccable character and qualifications” as he excoriated the judge’s decision.
“Judge Engoron challenges the highly respected Expert Witness for receiving fees, which is standard and accepted practice for Expert Witnesses,” Trump wrote on his social media platform Truth Social.
During testimony earlier this month, Bartov disputed the attorney general’s claims that Trump’s financial statements were filled with fraudulently inflated values for such signature assets as his Trump Tower penthouse and his Mar-a-Lago club in Florida.
Bartov said there was “no evidence whatsoever of any accounting fraud.”
But Engoron, in his ruling Monday, noted that he had already ruled that there were “numerous obvious errors” in Trump’s financial statements.
“By doggedly attempting to justify every misstatement, Professor Bartov lost all credibility,” the judge wrote.
In an email to The Associated Press, Bartov said he never “remotely implied” at the trial that Trump’s financial statements were “accurate in every respect,” only that the errors were inadvertent and there was “no evidence of concealment or forgery.”
Bartov also argued that he billed Trump at his standard rate.
Closing arguments are scheduled for Jan. 11 in Manhattan.
__
Associated Press reporter Michael Sisak in New York contributed to this story.
veryGood! (29772)
Related
- Why Kathy Bates Decided Against Reconstruction Surgery After Double Mastectomy for Breast Cancer
- Russia places spokesperson for Facebook parent Meta on wanted list
- Women falls to death down a well shaft hidden below rotting floorboards in a South Carolina home
- Hurry! These Extended Cyber Monday Sales Won't Last Forever: Free People, Walmart, Wayfair, & More
- Are Ciara Ready and Russell Wilson Ready For Another Baby? She Says…
- Sumatran rhino, critically endangered species, gives birth at Indonesian sanctuary: Watch
- Live updates | Israel and Hamas extend truce, agree to free more hostages and prisoners
- Finland plans to close its entire border with Russia over migration concerns
- Police capture Tennessee murder suspect accused of faking his own death on scenic highway
- 14-year-old boy charged with murder after stabbing at NC school kills 1 student, injures another
Ranking
- Pete Alonso's best free agent fits: Will Mets bring back Polar Bear?
- Body of man reported missing Nov. 1 found in ventilation system of Michigan college building
- Russian court extends detention of Wall Street Journal reporter Gershkovich until end of January
- Jimmy Carter set to lead presidents, first ladies in mourning and celebrating Rosalynn Carter
- New wildfires burn in US Northeast while bigger blazes rage out West
- Elon Musk visits Israel amid discussions on Starlink service in Gaza
- Inside the Weird, Wild and Tragically Short Life of Anna Nicole Smith
- Indonesia opens the campaign for its presidential election in February
Recommendation
-
Get Your Home Holiday-Ready & Decluttered With These Storage Solutions Starting at $14
-
As Dubai prepares for COP28, some world leaders signal they won’t attend climate talks
-
Massive crocodile sighting: Watch 14-foot 'Croczilla' in Florida Everglades
-
“Carbon Cowboys” Chasing Emissions Offsets in the Amazon Keep Forest-Dwelling Communities in the Dark
-
Wisconsin authorities believe kayaker staged his disappearance and fled to Europe
-
Taylor Swift's the 'Eras Tour' movie is coming to streaming with three bonus songs
-
Jennifer Lopez announces 'This Is Me…Now' album release date, accompanying movie
-
Purdue is new No. 1 as top of USA TODAY Sports men's basketball poll gets reshuffled